Bad Decision
$8.00
A graham cracker cookie meets a triple chocolate marshmallow-stuffed cookie, finished with fluff, chocolate, and graham cracker.
Ortonville, Michigan
Sugar Slut
Desserts with no shame.
Bold artisan cookies, outrageous layers, and Polish family recipes brought back to life by Jessica McClenahan.
Meet the menuNo shame, just sugar Baked in Ortonville No shame, just sugar Baked in Ortonville No shame, just sugar Baked in Ortonville No shame, just sugar Baked in Ortonville No shame, just sugar Baked in Ortonville No shame, just sugar Baked in Ortonville No shame, just sugar Baked in Ortonville No shame, just sugar Baked in Ortonville
The story
Born from obsession. Raised on tradition.
Sugar Slut is Jessica's love letter to baking, Polish heritage, and the grandmother whose recipes first made the kitchen feel like home.
After a 19-year gap from baking, she returned with a point of view: desserts should be generous, playful, and worth obsessing over. The name says exactly what it means.
Meet your baker
Jessica McClenahan
Jessica bakes each small batch with the same instinct her grandmother taught her: use the good ingredients, trust your hands, and never be stingy with the filling.
Cottage bakery Family rooted
Baked with obsession
The pleasure menu
Meet your next bad decision
Pillow Talk
$4.00
Soft strawberry shortbread drenched in white chocolate and covered in strawberry shortcake crumble.
Daddy Issues
$5.00
An outrageously rich chocolate chip cookie packed with crunchy honeycomb toffee.
Butter Me Daddy
$5.00
A thick blondie-style cookie with peanut butter chips, a buttery cookie crown, and peanut butter drizzle.
Hot Mess
$5.00
A cinnamon-swirled cookie with crunchy cereal, a brown sugar center, and cream cheese glaze.
Birthday Suit
$4.00
A soft vanilla cake batter cookie loaded with white chocolate, Golden Oreos, and rainbow sprinkles.
How it works
Three steps to sweet relief
01
Choose your trouble
Pick cookies, quantities, and add-ons from the menu.
02
Send the request
Share your date, contact preference, and any special notes.
03
Jessica confirms
You will receive availability, pickup details, and your final total personally.
Order request
Pick your pleasure
Build your request below. Availability and the final total are confirmed personally before your order is booked.
From Jessica's kitchen
Fresh, real, and unfiltered
Worth every crumb
Kind words
What customers are saying
“Every bite feels like somebody took a favorite family recipe, turned the flavor all the way up, and made it impossible to share.”
Good to know
Questions, answered
Is this a payment?+
No. The online form sends Jessica an order request. She will personally confirm availability, timing, and the final total before your order is booked.
Where is pickup?+
Pickup is arranged in Ortonville, Michigan. Exact details are shared when your order is confirmed.
Do you handle allergies?+
The kitchen works with wheat, milk, eggs, peanuts, and tree nuts. Share allergy details in your request so Jessica can discuss what is possible, but the kitchen is not allergen-free.
Can I order for a party?+
Absolutely. Use the notes field for dates, headcount, and the kind of celebration. Jessica will follow up with the best options.
Stay shameless
Follow the next sweet drop
Ortonville, Michigan